Mart Laar blog

Just do it!

Alexander Solzhenitsyn dead

One of the most important novelists in Russia in XX century Alexander Solzhenitsyn, is dead. Through his own and other victims accounts of the communist terror  Solzhenitsyn’s novels and nonfiction works exposed the secret history of the communist system that enslaved millions. Beginning with the 1962 short novel “One Day in the Life of Ivan Denisovich,” Solzhenitsyn devoted himself to describing the evils of communism. His “Gulag Archipelago” trilogy of the 1970s shocked Western readers by describing the savagery of the Soviet system, helping to erase sympathy for the Soviet Union among many leftist intellectuals. He did not compromise, he told the truth and expected other to do the same. For this and for his “ethical force” Solzhenitsy was awarded the Nobel Prize for Literature. In 1974 he was arrested on a treason charge and expelled to West in handcuffs. Living in America Solzhenitsyn tried to encourage West to fight the evil system of communism, but became more and more disappointed by Western moral relatevism. His criticizm Western culture for what he considered its weakness and decadence did not win him friends here either.  

After a triumphant return from exile in 1994 after collapse of communism Solzhenitsyn expressed annoyance and disappointment that most Russians hadn’t read his books. He was right: when Russians have done it, they have really condemned communism and build probably better Russia. Solzhenitsyn was ofcourse man with contradictions. As another famous Russian novelist Dostojevsky he was firm Russian nationalist and devoted Orthodox, condemning in harsh words by example independence of Ukraine. His role in fall of communism, his courage and moral stand make nevertheless from him one of the greatest Russians in history. 

RUSSIA TROUBLED WITH COMMUNISM

Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs attacked furiously President George Bush, who in his proclamation on Captive Nations Week said  that “In the 20th century, the evils of Soviet communism and Nazi fascism were defeated and freedom spread around the world as new democracies emerged”. Russia said that had insulted veterans of World War Two by equating the evils of Soviet communism with Nazi fascism. Ministry was specially angry that by their statement Bush had coupled Nazi fascism and Soviet communism as “a single evil” and thus “hurt the hearts” of World War Two veterans in Russia and allied countries, including the United States. “While condemning the abuse of power and unjustified severity of the Soviet regime’s internal policies, we nevertheless can neither treat indifferently attempts to equate Communism and Nazism nor agree that they were inspired by the same ideas and aims,” the ministry said in a statement. 

Actually the Bush statement is correct – there is really no big difference between Hitler Germany and Stalin Russia. Russian Ministry of Foreign Affairs does not want to rememeber, that Hitler did not launch II World War alone, but in close cooperation with Stalin via Molotov-Ribbentrop pact. The first free major campaigns of the war were Hitler’s attack against Poland 01.09.1939, Stalin’s attack against Poland 17.09.1939 and Stalins agression against Finland on the same year. One third of the all War – 1939-1941 – Stalin was most devoted supporter of Hitler – without Stalin’s help there has been no chance for Hitler to conquer most of Europe. Talking on the really large sacrificies of Russian people afterwards to fight down their former ally, the way how communist and nazis started this terrible war must be also remembered.

Wrong decision from European Union.

Last week European Union decided to lift sanctions against Cuban communistic regime, hoping probably so to encourage communist leaders to introduce democratic reforms. Such tactics has never worked with communists. They understand such gestures only as a signal, that they can do whatever they like. They demonstrated this faster as anybody expected. On the morning of Friday, June 20, former political prisoner and opposition leader Jorge Luis García Pérez “Antúnez,” his wife, human rights activist Iris Pérez Aguilera, and other opposition activists from various regions of Cuba were violently arrested by political police forces in the Versailles neighborhood in the city of Matanzas. The Cuban Democratic Directorate calls on international public opinion, especially on the European Union’s member states who eliminated diplomatic sanctions against the Raúl Castro regime, to condemn this human rights violation committed against Cuban citizens peacefully demanding respect for their rights. More information on situation in Cuba on www.communistcrimes.org

Foundation for Investigation of Communist Crimes

I am happy to announce, that the new web-page for investigation of communist crimes has been opened www.communistcrimes.org. The Foundation for the Investigation of Communist Crimes (FICC) was established on April 2008. The main priority of the Foundation is to inform the general public of the crimes committed by Communist/Socialist regimes in the name of Communist utopia. The Foundation’s webpage serves as a multilevel database and interactive portal providing easier access to various subjects related to Communist regimes, Communist ideology and post-Communist studies.

Besides dissemination and international research activities, the FICC promotes social, educational, advisory programs and specific projects developed with the support of institutional and private-sector partners around the world. The Foundation takes measures to publicize and memorialize the crimes of former and contemporary Communist regimes. With a series of programs and projects, the Foundation seeks to raise awareness of Communist crimes and support the democratic opposition of the last remaining Communist regimes, transitional societies and post-Communist states.

Over the last 15 years, many former Communist and Socialist states have debated their Communist past and established parliamentary and academic committees or commissions, research institutes or independent groups to investigate the crimes of the past, without an immediate purpose of organizing trials, but to establish and acknowledge facts about their past. Such truth commissions have assessed evidence and put together authoritative accounts of the Communist past.

Knowledge about the events of history and the recent pammediate purpose of organizing trials, but to establish and acknowledge facts about their past. Such truth commissions have assessed evidence and put together authoritative accounts of the Communist past.st is vital, as it constitutes a factual basis for open debate on the protection of natural liberties and the responsibilities of the political community. Common acknowledgement of historical facts has been and shall be a precondition for liberty. These facts, however, cannot be established without an open discussion on past events and injustices.

Post-Communist states willing to deal with political responsibility for past abuses must also decide on lustration, rehabilitation, compensation and the reassessment of history. But reconciliation with the past is not only a matter for state institutions, legislation, courts or truth commissions. The large amount of existing Communist crimes research must be brought to light and the public message conveyed more clearly. State-funded institutes, committees and commissions are conducting inquiries, exhaustive studies and archive research, but are often unfit to disseminate their conclusions. In this view, the FICC’s mission is to spread existing knowledge and make a difference in global awareness and understanding of Communism.

FSB seeks rehabilitation of Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact

Paul Goble has turned the attention to the FSB hosted roundtable on 22.April on “Problems of the Publication of Sources about the Great Fatherland War, Criticism of Attempts at the Falsification of History”. On Roundtable several participants stated that the Russian and foreign historians, novelists and filmmakers are falsifying the history of the second world war and the Soviet Union’s role in it. The President of the Association of Historians of the II WW Oleg Rzheshevsky called for the Russian parliament to overturn the 1989 condemnation of the “secret protocols” of the Molotov-Ribbentrop Pact. Rzheshevsky argued that the Stalin’s decision was justified. By Rzheshevsky most important what that Stalin defeated Hitler, which puts everything else that happened in those times in the other perspective, justifiying so Stalin’s crimes. This is only one example of the campaign in current Russia to restore the “historical truth” and protect the heritage of Soviet Union.     

First “results” of Bucharest Summit.

In NATO Summit in Bucharest some weeks ago Germany and France blocked the proposal to invite Ukraine and Georgia to participate in MAP (Membership Action Plan). It was explained, that such of step will give to new President of Russia Medvedev “fresh start” and decreases tensions in the region. Several memberstates warned that Russia will understand such gesture wrongly – namely Russia takes from this point granted, that Georgia and Ukraine will stay in his sphere of influence and Russia can do there whatever it likes. Unfortunately, that is what is happening. With only some weeks passed from Summit, Russia has raised stakes in Georgia, starting de facto recognition-process of Abkhazian and South-Ossetian separatist governments. In real terms it means annexation of Georgian territories by Russia. This increases significantly tensions in the region. When West could not react on Russian provocation effectively, this can turn the frozen conflicts in Caucasus to really hot.   

Europe discusses crimes of communism.

On 8 April 2008 European Commission has hearing on crimes committed by totalitarian regimes. Even as Commission is still afraid to name this hearing on crimes committed by communism, it is clear and positive step forward. It would be discussed how to improve knowledge about totalitarian crimes and how to promote public awareness about totalitarian crimes. Participants in hearing are experts from different memberstates, representatives of Commission and members of European Parliament. EPP as party has passed soon some years ago decision to urge its Parliamentary Group in European Parliament to initiate the declaration condemning the crimes of communism at the same way as crimes of nazism are condemned. Such declaration is soon passed by Parliamentary Assamble of Council of Europe. We can hope that with such hearings Europe moves nearer to the condemnation of communist crimes.

1941: Stalin and Hitler

I was asked by Georgi to give my opinion, did Stalin really planned to launch the pre-emptive strike against Hitler in summer 1941 as described in the books of Suvorov. My short answer is, yes, he planned. The only question is when exactly? I suggest to read not only Suvorov on this topic as he is not having access to Russian archives but some other historians do. By now the archives are mostly closed again. Probably the best book which is written internationally on this topic is from A.Pleshakov “Stalin’s folly”. You can easily find it in Amazon. In Russian the new book on the same topic is written by Mark Solonin. I wonder how so many western “classical historians” even now try to ignore this massive evidence on Soviet plans. This probably comes from attempt to forget the first period of WW II, when Stalin and Hitler were best allies. Stalin’s plans of course didn’t make Hitler innocent victim of bad Stalin as he is described to be innocent victim of Hitler. They both were criminals and murderers, both killed lot of people and burned books. It is only hard to understand why so many people still believe that one of them is better than another.

Katõn for Oscar

Yesterday “Oscar” nominees were announced. Among foreign movies one of the most interesting is A.Wajda’s “Katõn” which describes the massacre of Polish officers in 1940-1941 in Katõn by NKVD. Current Russia is not recognizing the crimes committed by the Stalin regime and attacking furiously the Wajda’s movie. At the same time the evidence of Soviet crimes was presented soon by President Jeltsin. Unfortunately the Katõn massacre is not so much known in Western countries. Nazi-Soviet conspiracy in 1939, the Molotov-Ribbentrop pact, start of II World War as a result of this and fate of Poland and Baltic countries has not been much discussed subject. Stalin joined in 1941 the Allied camp and his cooperation with Hitler during the first period of war was pardoned. At the same time it must remembered, that without Stalin and Molotov-Ribbentrop pact, II World War has probably never been started and Poland invaded from one side by Nazi-Germany and from other side by Soviet Union. This was reason why Wajda presented his movie in POland namely on 17. September 2007, remembering the day, when Soviet forces invaded Poland in 1939. Wajda’s movie is powerful story of forgotten crimes, memory and love. This is not autobiography, but tells story of these thousands of mothers, wives and children, who were not allowed to know truth what happened to their sons, husbands and fathers. Wajda’s movie deserves Oscar, let’s hope it would get it!

Van der Linden lies.

Yesterday I got mail from one Dutch friend, what I publish here.  remember that last year you had some “problems” with the chairman of the Assemblee of the Council of Europe Mr Rene van der Linden. Van der Linden had some strange and incorrect ideas about the situation and rights of the Russian-speaking population in Estonia. Today, will be the last day Van der Linden is chairman of this Assemblee. Therefore the day before yesterday (19 January) there was an interview with Van der Linden on the Dutch stateradio. In this interview he said that 28% of the Estonian population is stateless. This is not true. He also said that a few times per year Estonian people are marching the streets in nazi-uniforms. This also is not true. For me as a Dutchman, it is painfull to see that a Dutch top diplomat on such an important position can spread around so much nonsense and lies about your country. It seems that he let himself be used as a puppet in the Russian propaganda against Estonia. But as chairman of such an important international organisation this is not acceptable off course. Maybe you can do something with this false information or maybe your collegue Tunne Kelam could ask some questions in Brussels about the spreading of desinformation of Van der Linden. Best I can do, is really to publish this letter here in my homepage and hope, that more people will stand up against the lies. It is one thing, when You make mistakes, when You do not know. As a former President of ENPA Linden knows situation in Estonia very well.